hosted by tripod
Search: This Site Tripod Web by Lycos Search
Start Your Own Blog Today Build an online Photo Album

Torah Studies

Why Promise So Many Times?
Home
Meet Your Teacher
The Torah
The Law Of Love
Messianic Prophecies
Pronouncing His Name
Audio Bible
Studies In Genesis
Election And Rejection
Two Covenants With Noah
Election - Why Abraham
Abraham's Prayer For Sodom
An Ancient Water Fight
Isaac's Blessings For Both Sons
Jacob's Ladder
At The Well
Why Promise So Many Times?
Three Contracts
Simeon And Levi Are Brothers
From 'Jacob' To 'Israel'
Who Really Sold Joseph?
Joseph And His Brothers
Judah: Growing In Grace
Joseph's Repentance
Handling Disputes
Ephraim And Manasseh
Studies In Exodus
Moses And His Mother
Let My People Go
Religious Freedom
Slavery In Torah
Paid In Full
Basic Training In The Desert
I Am YHVH
Amalek
The Golden Calf
Compromise At Mount Sinai
The Ten Commandments
Did Moses Really Sin
The Sin Of The Spies
Balaam The Prophet
Gad And Reuben Wrongly Accused
Studies In Deuteronomy
The Tabernacle
Jerusalem
Deborah: Prophetess, Mother And Judge
Ruth And Boaz
Abigail As A Role Model
Samuel And Saul
Saul And Amalek
The Great Showdown
Elijah And Jonah
Spiritual Nakedness
Sodom And Israel
Gomer And Israel
Heart Of A Harlot
Israel's Prosperity
Dreams
Jewish Holidays
Jewish Wedding
Holiday Recipes
The Good News
Archives
How many times must YHVH repeat the same promise?

"When YHVH made His promise to Abraham, since there was no one greater for Him to swear by, He swore by Himself, saying, 'I will surely bless you and give you many descendants.'" Hebrews 6:13-14
How many times must YHVH repeat the same promise to Abraham? YHVH tells Abraham four times that his offspring ('seed') will become a nation in a special land. Would not have one divine promise been sufficient?

After the events of Tower of Babel, YHVH came to Abraham and initiated a special relationship with him in order that he become the forefather of His special (model) nation that would direct mankind toward a more spiritual existence.

"I will make you a great nation... and through you all nations of the world will be blessed..." (Gen 12:1-3)

YHVH's next appearance to Abraham was upon his fulfilling his first instructions, his arrival in that land:

"To your 'seed' (offspring) I shall give this Land" (Gen 12:7)

To become that nation, Abraham's family will need to multiply, and hence the blessing of 'seed'; and there must be a certain territory wherein his offspring can establish this nation. This concept of "seed" & "land" will be mentioned together in almost every other appearance as well!

Theoretically speaking, these two promises could have been enough. Now that Abraham has arrived in the land, he should be able to start a family, have many children, and settle the land, thus establishing this special nation. But as we know, becoming YHVH's nations is not a simple thing, rather it unfolds as a long and complicated process. To appreciate that process, we must understand the reason for each additional appearance and revelation to Abraham.

 

The First Split


YHVH's next appearance to Abraham took place after his quarrel with Lot. (Gen 13:1-14) Here we find yet another divine promise of "seed and land"

"And YHVH spoke to Abram after Lot had left him: Lift up your eyes from this place and see... for this entire land which you see I am giving to you and your seed forever..." (Gen 13:14-18)

This promise, although a bit more 'poetic' than the first, appears to be more or less a repeat of YHVH's original promise. Why then was it necessary for YHVH to repeat it?

To understand why, consider the fact that this promise followed three different events in Abraham's life which took place in the interim:

1)Avraham's descent and return from Egypt (Gen 12:10 - 13:4) 2)The quarrel between Lot and Abraham (Gen 13:5-13)
3)YHVH's promise to Abraham of "seed and land" (Gen 13:14-18) The simple reason for the quarrel between Lot and Abraham was due to their wealth (13:5-6). However, it was because of their journey to Egypt that Abraham & Lot became wealthy. (12:16,20, & 13:1,2,5) Therefore, upon their return, the land was not 'big enough' for all of their new possessions, (13:6) thus leading to the quarrel. (13:7)  YHVH's promise came to 'encourage' Abraham after this tragic separation from his nephew Lot. (13:14)

There may be another explanation as well. Abraham had no children and his nephew Lot has no father. Therefore, Abraham treated Lot like his own son. In fact, from the moment we meet Abraham, Lot faithfully follows him everywhere. (Gen 11:27-31;12:4-5 & 13:1,2,5)

Abraham may have thought that through Lot, YHVH's promise of "seed" would be fulfilled! And even if YHVH would bless him with his own son, Abraham could still include Lot as an integral member of his 'chosen' family. Therefore, Lot's decision to leave could be considered a personal tragedy for Abraham but a 'necessity' in the election/rejection process!

 

Leaving Abraham or Leaving YHVH?

This background allows us to view the story of Lot and Abraham as the first example of apparent "elimination", when a member of Abraham's family is 'kicked out'. In fact, many of the stories in the book of Genesis explain how this process of "elimination" unfolds, and why! This incident with Lot is a classic example.

Let's also remember that Lot's choice of the Jordan Valley was not the compromise that Abraham had suggested. Abraham offered Lot to go either north (left) or south (right) - Gen 13:9 - a choice between the hills of Judah or Samaria; not a complete separation, only a far enough distance to avoid quarrels.

Instead, Lot chose to leave the mountain range altogether, preferring the Jordan Valley instead, going eastward! (13:10-11) The 'technical reason', because the Jordan Valley had a river, a constant supply of water - in contrast to the mountain range whose water supply was dependent on the rainfall.

However, Lot's choice carried spiritual ramifications as well. "For the land which you are coming to inherit is not like the land of Egypt (which has the Nile River as a constant water supply), instead it is a land of hills and valleys - which needs rain for water. Therefore it is a land which YHVH looks after..." (Deut 11:10-12)
Lot's choice reflected his preference for a different life-style. Abraham accepted the challenge of The Land - a life dependent on rain and hence - dependent on YHVH. (Deut 11:13-16) Lot however, prefered the 'easy-life' in Sodom. By making this choice Lot removed himself further away from YHVH, as if saying, I can no longer remain with Abraham - nor with his ELOHIM.

Lot's total 'divorce' from Abraham was indeed sad, for Abraham had lost not only a 'son' but also a 'disciple'. Therefore, YHVH must now not only console him, but also reassure him that despite Lot's departure, His promise of "seed and land" remained. Indeed, Abraham will yet have a child - a son who will follow in his father's footsteps as well.

It may have been Lot's own experience in Egypt, seeing the 'good-life', that led him to reject Abraham's offer, and chose the Jordan Valley instead:

"And Lot lifted his eyes and saw the entire Jordan valley, for it had a plentiful supply of water... like the land of Egypt..." (Gen 13:10)

In contrast to Lot, Abraham who remained 'chosen' reacted to his experience in Egypt in a totally different manner. Abraham, after his incident with Pharaoh and Sarah, saw corruption in Egypt. He returned to The Land determined to have nothing to do with the sort of corruption. Upon his return, Abraham traveled immediately to Beth-El, and once again called out in YHVH's Name.

 

The First Covenant - 'Between The Pieces'

 

To better appreciate this promise, we must remember the war of the five kings against the four kings in chapter 14. In this battle, we saw Abraham for the first time as a man of war, a conqueror. It was this military victory that led Abraham to the realization of how important it was that he have a successor. "After these events, YHVH spoke to Abram in a vision saying: Do not be fearful... I will shield you, your reward is very great..." (Gen 15:1-2) There is one point that Abraham raised over and over again in his ensuing conversation that definitely related to his military conquest, as well as his lack of a son:

"...Since you have given me no offspring, behold my house servant, Eliezer, he will be my heir..." (15:3)

Abraham realized that without a son, everything that he has acquired will be taken over by his servant Eliezer. "And YHVH answered: That one Eliezer, will not be your heir. Rather your very own son (yet to be born) - he will be your heir... Then He said to him: I am YHVH who brought you out of Ur of the Chaldees, to give you this land to inherit it... then Abraham asked - whereby shall I know that I shall inherit it..." (Gen 15:4-8)

There can be no doubt that "inheritance" is the key word in this conversation, but what does it mean?

Throughout Torah, "inheritance" almost always implies military conquest, usually by a sovereign nation (or to become one). Here too, after his military victory, Abraham wanted to know how his offspring will one day gain sovereignty over this land!

In the Covenant 'Between the Pieces, we find the answer to Abraham's question: YHVH informed him that indeed his offspring will one day conquer the land. However, this conquest will take place only after several generations of bondage in a foreign land, after which they will gain their independence and their oppressors shall be punished. (Gen 15:13-16)

Therefore, in the aftermath of the war of the kings, an additional promise of "seed and land" must be made, one which explains how Abraham's seed will become a nation.

 

Land for Purpose


The order of events which unfolded in this Covenant 'Between the Pieces' was quite significant, for it highlighted the nature of our relationship to the land of Israel. Most nations first begin by a group of people living in a common land. (First, we find a common land, and hence common needs, and then a common nation)  Israel, however,will become a nation in a very different manner. The Nation of Israel did not begin with a common land, but rather with a common goal (or destiny), to become YHVH's model nation. As the Torah emphasized, Israel will become a nation in a "land that is not theirs" (Gen 15:13)  Technically speaking, their initial bonding was caused by a common plight and suffering in a foreign land. Only after they became a nation, and only after they received the Torah at Mount Sinai (the laws that teach how to achieve this goal), only then did they conquer the Land that YHVH had designated for them.

In other words, Israel did not become a nation because they had common land, rather they became a nation because they shared a common goal, and to achieve that goal YHVH promised a special land.

 

The Birth of Ishmael - - Gen 16:1-6


YHVH promised that Ishmael too will become a mighty nation, but a rather wild one. (Gen 16:12) For some divine reason, YHVH's intention was that Abraham's only chosen will be born to Sarah, but only after her lifelong struggle with barrenness.

However, before Abram and Sarai could give birth to this special child, YHVH had to change their names to Abraham and Sarah and enter into yet another covenant  ---Circumcision.

 

The Covenant Of Circumcision


The covenant of circumcision (Gen 17:1-11) contained the fourth and final promise of "seed and land" to Abraham. It  included the very first mitzva (commandment) that Abraham had to keep and pass on to his children - its details were very important, even to this day.